Twenty-nine players were chosen as first-team selections on the IBCA Boys' Academic All-State Team. An additional 146 players were selected as honorable mention Academic All-State. Coaches may pick up their player's certificate at the IBCA Spring Clinic on April 27-28, 2012.
If you do not plan to attend the clinic, please make arrangements for another coach to pick up your player’s certificate.
Boys Academic All-State First Team
| Player | School | Coach |
| Basel Allaw | Evansville Day | Kelly Ballard |
| Trent Brown | Perry Central | Matt Carter |
| John Eckert | North Judson-San Pierre | Phil Shabi |
| Brian Failinger | Indianapolis Lutheran | Tom Finchum |
| Ryan Frantz | Maconquah | Lucas Zartman |
| Ben Gardner | Carmel | Scott Heady |
| Lucas Grose | Warsaw | Doug Ogle |
| Brad Hartman | Union County | Mark Detweiler |
| David Heckman | Roncalli | Michael Wantz |
| John Herzog | Milan | Josh Blankinship |
| Andrew Johnson | Orleans | Tom Bradley |
| Jalen King | Lakeland | Ryan Yoder |
| Connor Kirtley | Seymour | Scott Miller |
| Louis Kissinger | Goshen | Brian Bechtel |
| Jeff Laidig | Penn | Al Rhodes |
| Mike Lenz | Brebeuf Jesuit | Scott McClelland |
| James Lisman | Sullivan | Jeff Moore |
| Jonathan McKeeman | Carroll (Fort Wayne) | Marty Beasley |
| Quinton Miller | Floyd Central | Randy Gianfagna |
| Adam Miller | Hauser | Bob Nobbe |
| Robert Mischler | Mishawaka Marian | Robb Berger |
| Brady Mouzin | Vincennes Rivet | Adam Ballard |
| Caleb Nicley | Western Boone | Kyle Spray |
| Lewis Nugent | North Daviess | Brent Dalrymple |
| Daniel Purvlicis | Noblesville | Dave McCollough |
| Riley Rapp | Guerin Catholic | Pete Smith |
| Joe Reed | Center Grove | Cliff Hawkins |
| Jordan Richardson | New Castle | Steve Bennett |
| Kyle Wuest | Edinburgh | Drew Glentzer |
Boys Academic All-State Honorable Mention
| Player | School | Coach |
| Michael Anderson | Highland | Eddie Fierek |
| Brock Armstrong | Logansport | Mark Victor |
| Logan Barker | Martinsville | Tim Wolf |
| Caleb Beaman | South Knox | Joe Patton |
| Lucas Beavers | Rushville | Brian Brown |
| Grant Benefiel | Monrovia | Chris Sampson |
| Cam Biggs | Logansport | Mark Victor |
| Adam Botts | Muncie Central | Matt Fine |
| Michael Bower | Bloomington South | J.R. Holmes |
| Nick Boyd | Castle | Brian Gibson |
| Ben Braunecker | Forest Park | Nate Hawkins |
| Nathan Brown | East Noble | Vince Beasley |
| Garnett Bucher | Norwell | Randy Hawkins |
| Jake Clark | Wawasee | Phil Mishler |
| Reid Clark | New Palestine | Adam Barton |
| Lane Clark | North Vermillion | Sam Karr |
| Nathan Cobine | Eastern Greene | Andy Igel |
| Brandon Collins | New Palestine | Adam Barton |
| Matthew Conrad | Lapel | Jimmie Howell |
| Jordan Cox | North Posey | Matt Wadsworth |
| Jordan Crabb | Twin Lakes | Kent Adams |
| Curtis Crow | Springs Valley | Josh Thompson |
| Sam Curts | Carmel | Scott Heady |
| Alex Dall | Hamilton Southeastern | Brian Satterfield |
| Evan Deckard | Bedford N. Lawrence | Jamie Hudson |
| Brady Dolezal | Tipton | Brad Dickey |
| Luke Dougherty | Whiteland Community | Brandon Sorrell |
| Seth Dow | Martinsville | Tim Wolf |
| Jacob Drapla | FW Canterbury | Dan Kline |
| Tyler Duffy | Hamilton Southeastern | Brain Satterfield |
| Steve Durr | Sheridan | Cory Dunn |
| Jake Dye | Tipton | Brad Dickey |
| Dustin Echard | Northfield | Moe Smedley |
| Billy Edelen | Clarksville | Jason Cornell |
| Brian Failinger | Indianapolis Lutheran | Tom Finchum |
| Kyle Faucett | Adams Central | Aaron McClure |
| Jake Fella | Heritage Hills | Matt Sisley |
| Bradley Fey | Roncalli | Michael Wantz |
| Keaton Fiechter | Adams Central | Aaron McClure |
| Matt Filipek | Whiting | Derrick Milenkoff |
| Luke Forston | Tecumseh | Kevin Oxley |
| Todd Frickey | Garrett | John Bodey |
| Luke Galle | Columbus East | Brent Chitty |
| Kyle Galovich | Homestead | Christ Johnson |
| Brandon Gay | Columbia City | Chris Benedict |
| Josh Gill | Goshen | Brian Bechtel |
| Tanner Ginder | Carroll (Fort Wayne) | Marty Beasley |
| Jonathan Gingerich | Barr-Reeve | Bryan Hughes |
| Chad Glasscock | Northfield | Moe Smedley |
| Tyler Goodall | Columbus North | Jason Speer |
| Alex Gordon | Wapahani | Matt Luce |
| Jace Gordon | Northeast Dubois | Terry Friedman |
| Bryan Hall | Guerin Catholic | Pete Smith |
| Aaron Hill | Riverton Parke | Charlie Martin |
| Mark Hetzer | Oldenburg Academy | Gary Moorman |
| Trevor Hoover | Caston | Ben Snyder |
| Adam Hufford | Guerin Catholic | Pete Smith |
| Mitch Huppert | Bremen | Ryan Eakins |
| Jordan Hyland | Oldenburg Academy | Gary Moorman |
| Scott Jerge | Munster | Mike Hackett |
| Grant Keaffaber | Southwood | John Burrus |
| Kyle Kamman | Columbus North | Jason Speer |
| Matt Kaplanis | Blackhawk Christian | Jay Sefton |
| Chandler Kauffman | Fairfield | Troy Beachy |
| Warren Kay | Goshen | Brian Bechtel |
| Alex Kilgore | New Castle | Steve Bennett |
| Kurtis Kimla | Milan | Josh Blankinship |
| Keegan Kincaid | Switzerland County | BJ McAlister |
| Lynk Kordes | Forest Park | Nate Hawkins |
| Kyle Krohn | Winamac | Kyle Johnson |
| Evan Kruger | West Central | Bryan Heimlich |
| Austin Kyker | Park Tudor | Ed Schilling |
| Brandt Lawyer | North Daviess | Brent Dalrymple |
| Miles Leonard | Forest Park | Nate Hawkins |
| Conor Levey | South Bend St. Joseph's | Marty Harshman |
| Trevor Litt | Franklin Central | John Rockey |
| Brett Luchbihler | FW Bishop Dwenger | Matt Kostoff |
| Ryan McNeil | Plymouth | Ryan Bales |
| Jake Meyer | Forest Park | Nate Hawkins |
| James Miller | North Central | Doug Mitchell |
| Tyler Mink | Heritage Christian | Kyle Bloom |
| Brian Moore | Twin Lakes | Kent Adams |
| Jordan Morning | Winamac | Kyle Johnson |
| Jordan Munden | Hamilton Heights | Chad Ballenger |
| Karson Nixon | Jasper | John Goebel |
| Jeremy Noe | Clarksville | Jason Cornell |
| Matt O'Leary | Terre Haute North | Todd Woelfe |
| Gavin O'Neal | Floyd Central | Randy Giantagna |
| Eric Osterman | Evansville Central | Scott Hudson |
| John Pauer | Hebron | John Steinhilber |
| Alex Payne | Mt. Vernon (Fortville) | Steve Lynch |
| J.P. Pena | Fishers | Joe Leonard |
| Jacob Price | Noblesville | David McCollough |
| Adam Price | Heritage Hills | Matt Sisley |
| Jayson Pundy | Jac-Cen-Del | David Bradshaw |
| Grant Randle | University | Paul Gianakos |
| Clayton Randolph | North Harrison | Joel Grindle |
| Davis Rao | Canterbury | Dan Kline |
| JB Rapp | Park Tudor | Ed Schilling |
| Jason Ray | Martinsville | Tim Wolf |
| Matt Rethlake | Columbia City | Chris Bendict |
| Dillon Reynolds | Northview | Ernie Maesch |
| Wes Rittman | Clarksville | Jason Cornell |
| John Michael Rodrick | North Knox | Aaron Hall |
| Cole Rohleder | Jasper | John Goebel |
| John Michael Ruff | Plymouth | Ryan Bales |
| Nick Ryan | Milan | Josh Blankinship |
| Spencer Sacks | Marquette Catholic | Donovan Garlette |
| Matt Sampson | Monrovia | Chris Sampson |
| Tyler Sandmann | East Central | David Disbro |
| Cole Schafer | Evansville Harrison | Bryan Speer |
| Tate Schienbein | Union County | Mark Detweiler |
| Bauer Schmeltz | Wawasee | Phil Mishler |
| Derek Self | Manchester | Eric Thompson |
| Payton Selking | Bellmont | John Baker |
| Cole Shafer | Maconaquah | Lucas Zaitman |
| Sam Sheldon | Bloomington North | Adndrew Hodson |
| Alex Shrum | Hebron | John Steinhilber |
| Joel Smith | Heritage Christian | Kyle Bloom |
| Zach Smith | Yorktown | Greg Miller |
| Logan Smith | Bellmont | John Baker |
| Lincoln Smith | South Knox | Joe Patton |
| Michael Sordelet | FW Bishop Dwenger | Matt Kostoff |
| Ross Sponsler | Terre Haute North | Todd Woelfe |
| Mitchell Stevenson | Wheeler | Tom Johnson |
| Kyle Stidom | Greenwood Christian | Jamie Satre |
| Caleb Strabavy | Whiting | Derrick Milenkoff |
| Nick Swartz | Pendleton Heights | Brian Hahn |
| Benjamin Taylor | Winamac | Kyle Johnson |
| Zach Taylor | Hamilton Southeastern | Brian Satterfield |
| Cole Toner | Roncalli | Michael Wantz |
| Brice Urschel | Blackhawk Christian | Jay Sefton |
| J.D. Volz | Boonville | Steve Altstadt |
| Braden Voss | Milan | Josh Blankinship |
| Daniel Wagner | Bishop Chatard | Travis Daughtery |
| Ashton Wagler | Barr-Reeve | Bryan Hughes |
| Damon Wahl | Heritage Hills | Matt Sisley |
| Devon Wahl | Heritage Hills | Matt Sisley |
| Nick Walter | Milan | Josh Blankinship |
| Dan Warnke | Westville | Rob Walker |
| Tegan Wild | Blackhawk Christian | Jay Sefton |
| Mitch Williams | Cloverdale | Pat Rady |
| Andrew Wilson | Whiteland Community | Brandon Sorrell |
| Taylor Wissel | South Knox | Joe Patton |
| Lucas Wolters | South Knox | Joe Patton |
| Reid Zimmerman | Blackhawk Christian | Jay Sefton |
